Helene Relief: 10% off all Wood Chippers
Use Coupon Code RELIEF at checkout

Y-Blades vs. Hammer Blades on a Flail Mower: A Hands-On Comparison

Hey everyone, welcome back! Today, we’re tackling a question I get asked all the time: What’s the difference between Y-blades and hammer blades on a flail mower, and which one should you choose? Since these blades are interchangeable, you might be wondering if it’s worth switching from one to the other based on your needs.

Well, I decided to put both blade types to the test. We’ll compare a flail mower equipped with hammer blades to one with Y-blades.

TopicOverview
IntroductionComparison between Y-blades and hammer blades on a flail mower to determine which is better suited for different mowing needs.
Flail Mowers and Their BladesUsing the EMSD series flail mower with hydraulic side-shift and tilt features on a 64-inch variant with a John Deere 3035D tractor (35 HP).
Testing Conditions
  • Grassy and Weedy Areas: Lush green areas with standard grasses and weeds.
  • Woody and Stemmy Areas: Patches with thicker, woodier vegetation.
  • Mixed Areas: Combination of both, some previously cut and some not.
Observations
  • Sound and Feel: Hammer blades are louder and feel more robust; Y-blades are quieter and sleeker.
  • Performance in Grassy Areas: Both blades provide consistent cuts; hammer blades may strain the engine more due to heavier design.
  • Performance in Woody Areas: Hammer blades excel with minimal leftovers; Y-blades leave more stems and require additional passes.
  • Durability and Maintenance: Hammer blades handle rocks better; both blade types are easy to maintain with individually replaceable blades.
Which Blade Should You Choose?

Hammer Blades

  • Best For: Tackling thick, woody, and stemmy vegetation.
  • Ideal Use: Fields and areas not mowed regularly.
  • Considerations: Louder operation; may strain smaller tractors.

Y-Blades

  • Best For: Finer grasses and regular lawn maintenance.
  • Ideal Use: Areas with just grasses and weeds.
  • Considerations: Quieter operation; less strain on tractor; may require multiple passes in thicker vegetation.
Final ThoughtsBlades are interchangeable, allowing flexibility. Choose the blade type that aligns with your primary mowing needs for convenience and cost-effectiveness.

Leave a comment below if you have any questions or insights to share. If you want to see more content like this, make sure to subscribe. And if you’re in the market for something for your tractor, don’t forget to check out Victory Tractor Implements.


Victory Flail Mower Compatibility Tool – Which Mower Will Fit Your Tractor?

Verify tractor specs with tractordata.com


Flail Mowers and Their Blades

Let’s start by talking about the flail mowers themselves. We’re using the EMSD Standard Duty Embankment Flail Mower series, which we’ve discussed before. These mowers come with a hydraulic side-shift and tilt feature, allowing you to extend the mower far out to the side and rotate vertically. This is great for ditches and banks with options for compact and small compact tractors.

For this test, we’re using a 64-inch variant on a John Deere 3035D, a 35-horsepower tractor with about 30 horsepower at the PTO.


Testing Conditions

We have a variety of mowing conditions to put these blades through their paces:

  • Grassy and Weedy Areas: Lush green areas with standard grasses and weeds.
  • Woody and Stemmy Areas: Patches with thicker, woodier vegetation.
  • Mixed Areas: A combination of both, some of which have been cut before and some that haven’t.

Your terrain and vegetation might differ, but we’ll work with what we have to provide some useful data points.


Observations

After running both mowers through the different areas, here are my key takeaways:

1. Sound and Feel

  • Hammer Blades: The mower equipped with hammer blades seemed louder and felt more robust, almost as if it could power through anything.
  • Y-Blades: The Y-blade mower was noticeably quieter and seemed sleeker, which aligns with their intended uses. Y-blades are designed for finer grasses and can even be used to mow your lawn.

2. Performance in Grassy Areas

  • Both mowers handled the grassy and weedy areas well, providing a consistent cut.
  • The hammer blades seemed to put a bit more strain on the engine, possibly due to their heavier design.

3. Performance in Woody Areas

  • Hammer Blades: This is where the hammer blades really shined. They did a superior job of cutting through thick, woody stems with minimal leftovers.
  • Y-Blades: Left behind noticeably more stems and stalks, meaning you’d have more cleanup or need multiple passes to achieve the same result.

4. Durability and Maintenance

  • Low Cutting Height: Flail mowers cut at a low height, just a few inches off the ground, which can sometimes lead to hitting rocks.
  • Blade Durability: The hammer blades handled occasional rocks well, even chipping away at them without significant damage.
  • Easy Maintenance: If you do break a blade, both types are individually replaceable with just a small bolt and nut—making maintenance a breeze.

Which Blade Should You Choose?

So, which blade is right for you?

Hammer Blades

  • Best For: Tackling thick, woody, and stemmy vegetation.
  • Ideal Use: Fields and areas that aren’t mowed regularly.
  • Considerations: Slightly louder operation and may put more strain on smaller tractors.

Y-Blades

  • Best For: Finer grasses and regular lawn maintenance.
  • Ideal Use: Areas with just grasses and weeds.
  • Considerations: Quieter operation and less strain on the tractor but may require multiple passes in thicker vegetation.

If you’re primarily dealing with fields similar to what we have here—tough brush and uneven terrain—the hammer blades are the way to go. If you’re mowing your lawn or areas with just grasses and weeds, the Y-blades might be more appropriate.

Remember, you don’t have to stress too much about the decision upfront. The blades are interchangeable, so you can switch them out later if your needs change. It’s just more convenient (and cost-effective) to choose the blade type that aligns with your primary use from the start.


Final Thoughts

As always, I’d love to hear your thoughts. Leave a comment below if you have any questions or experiences to share. Don’t forget to subscribe for more updates, and if you’re looking for something for your tractor, check out Victory Tractor Implements.

Well, it’s dinner time, and I’m hungry! Thanks so much for stopping by, and until next time, stay safe and happy mowing!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What are the main differences between Y-blades and hammer blades on a flail mower?

Answer: The primary differences between Y-blades and hammer blades involve their design, performance, and ideal applications:

  • Y-Blades: Shaped like the letter “Y,” these blades are lighter and designed for cutting finer grasses and weeds. They provide a cleaner, more manicured cut and are suitable for regular lawn maintenance. Y-blades operate more quietly and put less strain on the tractor’s engine.
  • Hammer Blades: Resembling small hammers, these blades are heavier and more robust. They’re built to tackle thicker, woody, and stemmy vegetation, making them ideal for fields and overgrown areas that aren’t mowed regularly. Hammer blades may generate more noise and can put additional strain on smaller tractors due to their heavier design.

2. Which blade type should I choose for my specific mowing needs?

Answer: Your choice depends on the primary type of vegetation you plan to mow:

  • Choose Y-Blades if:
    • You’re primarily cutting fine grasses and weeds.
    • You intend to use the flail mower for regular lawn maintenance.
    • You prefer a quieter operation with less strain on your tractor.
  • Choose Hammer Blades if:
    • You’re dealing with thick, woody, or stemmy vegetation.
    • You’re maintaining fields or areas that aren’t mowed regularly.
    • You’re okay with a slightly louder operation and your tractor can handle the extra strain.

Remember, both blade types are interchangeable on most flail mowers, so you can switch them out if your mowing needs change.

3. Can I interchange Y-blades and hammer blades on my flail mower?

Answer: Yes, the blades on most flail mowers, including the EMSD series used in our tests, are interchangeable. Both Y-blades and hammer blades are individually attached using small bolts and nuts, making it straightforward to replace or swap them as needed. This flexibility allows you to adapt your mower to different conditions without having to purchase a new machine.

4. How do Y-blades and hammer blades perform in different mowing conditions?

Answer:

  • Grassy and Weedy Areas: Both blade types handle these conditions well, providing a consistent and clean cut. Y-blades may offer a slightly finer finish suitable for lawns.
  • Woody and Stemmy Areas: Hammer blades excel in these conditions, effectively cutting through thick, woody stems with minimal leftovers. Y-blades may struggle, leaving behind more stems and requiring additional passes.
  • Mixed Areas: If you’re dealing with a combination of grasses and woody plants, hammer blades might be more efficient overall, despite being louder and heavier on the engine.

5. What considerations are there regarding durability and maintenance for each blade type?

Answer:

  • Durability:
    • Hammer Blades: More robust and can handle occasional impacts with rocks or hard objects without significant damage.
    • Y-Blades: While durable for their intended use, they may be more susceptible to damage in rough conditions with rocks or heavy debris.
  • Maintenance:
    • Both blade types are easy to maintain, as each blade is individually replaceable with a simple bolt and nut system.
    • Regular inspection is recommended to ensure blades are in good condition and securely attached.
  • Cutting Height and Terrain:
    • Flail mowers cut at a low height (just a few inches off the ground), increasing the risk of hitting rocks or uneven terrain.
    • Being mindful of your mowing environment can help extend the life of your blades, regardless of type.

Italian Trulli

Victory Tractor Implements is proud to offer a wide range of products including flail mowers, wood chippers, rotary tillers, and backhoes, all designed to be connected directly to your tractor’s PTO for maximum efficiency and performance. In addition, we also offer winter equipment such as snow plows and snow blowers, designed for use with skid steers.

We source all of our equipment directly from the manufacturer and pass the savings on to our customers.  As always, the team is standing by to answer any questions to assist with your decision.  Victory support can be reached directly at (562) 534-8182 or sales@etractorimplements.com

Share:

Facebook
Twitter
Pinterest
Tumblr
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Social Media

Recent Comments

Most Popular

Get The Latest Updates

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

No spam, notifications only about new products, updates.

Categories

What Our Customers Are Saying

Philip Jones
Philip Jones
16:30 15 Jul 24
Very good service in terms of shipping. The flail mower is very rugged. Used about 10 hours so far. It looks like it... will last a long time. As good or better than name brands at 1/3 the cost.read more
G M
G M
18:11 10 Jun 24
Great company that backs up their product.
Gerald Mckenney
Gerald Mckenney
01:29 05 May 24
Arrived in less than a week, well packaged and works as advertised.
Matt Moore
Matt Moore
19:20 12 Apr 24
Just received my 64 Heavy Duty Flail mower.1. They answered the phone when I called, and answered my questions.2. ... Shipped free, with good tracking along the way.3. Arrived on the date they estimated, with very little assembly.4. Great price.They were not my first choice, but out of the three I was considering they were the only ones to answer the phone right away and walk me through some details. The whole transaction was seamless. Glad I found them. I will buy from them again.read more
Raymond Dalton
Raymond Dalton
13:52 10 Apr 24
John Heathcote
John Heathcote
01:23 07 Apr 24
Great product! Even more heavy duty than I expected. Will last for many years.
Ethan Russell
Ethan Russell
15:31 17 Dec 23
We would definitely recommend. The hydraulic snow plow, that we ordered, arrived ahead of schedule and very well... packaged. Very professional group and capable group. American know how on display.read more
Eric James
Eric James
12:50 24 Jul 23
Unit very well built shipped as quoted and crated well.I like the design with the gearbox outside of the mower as it... keeps the shaft less acute when offset.spiral shaft is a plus in regard to staying in balance broke one grease zirk Brass? all in all very happy!!read more
Bonnie Romanski
Bonnie Romanski
15:45 26 Jun 23
Well built, easily assembly.
Jeff Sweeting
Jeff Sweeting
21:38 25 Jun 23
Awesome experience! From the ordering process to the shipment, everything was as they said it would be. Setup was easy,... only had one hiccup with infeed roller direction , called them and it was taken care of in literally 10 minutes. Great product, great service, great people!! Will buy from again in a heatbeat!!Jeff Sweeting,WWA Farm & Garden ServicesAlfred , ME 04002read more
Wirenut 901
Wirenut 901
21:16 24 Jun 23
Very happy with my new Victory flail mower. I had a couple of minor fitment issues but nothing an angle grinder and a... drill couldn't fix. This mower is a beast weighing in over 1,000 lbs. Very heavy duty. I couldn't be happier especially when it was half the price of the name brands. The guys at Victory picked up the phone every time I called and were eager to answer my questions. Thanks Victory !read more
Johnny Rhew
Johnny Rhew
22:20 21 Jan 23
Adjusted the blade clearance after a few jams. No problems now. Heavy built and chips 4 inch no problem. Would probably... handle the 5 inch. Very satisfied.read more
Richard Helms
Richard Helms
20:49 17 Nov 22
The EMID-70 embankment mower arrived in a metal cage on a wood pallet. The mower and accessories arrived in good... condition.The assembly was easy and straightforward. After assembly, all bolts and connections were verified tight and the gearbox was filled with 80W90 oil and all fittings greased. Hooking up to the tractor was made easy using the two parking stands that come with the unit. Once attached to the three point hitch the hydraulic hoses were connected using the hoses and fittings supplied. Once the hydraulic system was filled and the air bleed out it was time to work. The mower was ran for about 10 hours in all positions from 90 degrees up to 30 degrees down with no problems. After mowing the field the mower was used to trim the limbs that were encroching on the field.Suggestions for the shipping cage are add a middle bar between the upper and lower part of the cage and use locking bolts on the assembly as a few were loose or missing. The mower and accessories had shifted and fallen out and came on a wood pallet added bt the freight company.read more
James Allred
James Allred
10:52 19 Sep 22
Product came in very quickly. For the price I expected much less quality. Instead the quality seems really good and... it does a great job in grass or brush. Very happy with it.read more
d k
d k
11:28 17 Sep 22
I bought an EMSD-56 Embankment Flail Mower Standard Duty. I pre-ordered it in February. This had to be one of the most... difficult years ever as China still had a zero covid policy. As soon as the mower was set to ship the port of Shanghai closed for over 2 months so delivery could not be made as agreed. I was offered a refund or an additional discount at that time. I opted for the additional discount. It took a while but finally the mower made it's way to me and it works fine. What I can say is that the team at this business is totally fair and extremely trustworthy. I would use them again for another implement.read more
Tom Mayes
Tom Mayes
17:40 10 Sep 22
Purchase of Flail mower was simple, arrived in good condition and assembly was straight forward. The only issue was it... was set up for Cat 2 rather than Cat 1 but that was handled quickly with a new set of pins which were mailed to me and arrived within 3 days. Mower has been used only once to mow about 2 acres and worked wellread more
Ryan Talsma
Ryan Talsma
11:25 31 Jul 22
Just bought the emid-64. No assembly instructions included but got it done. I have used it for about 2 hours now. Very... nice unit, cuts great, heavy duty with grease fittings on all moving points. Smooth operation and comes with flow control so no jerky operation. Great so far... I did find that on the website has a full manual including assembly instructions..read more
Harold Weaver
Harold Weaver
15:44 29 Jul 22
Happy with my 60” tiller. Lot of tiller for the price. Had an issue with pto shaft but they have great customer... service. Thanks again Uwe.read more
Joe Bell
Joe Bell
23:20 17 May 22
Great people to deal with. I have the 78” flail mower and I love it. It gives a clean cut and runs smoothly.
Michael Treffinger
Michael Treffinger
22:51 23 Apr 22
I purchased the BX42S wood chipper. Shipping was quick and well crated. I've used it now for over 15hrs and it works... perfectly! I cleared woods for a motorcycle track and now I use this to clean up and help loosen up the soil with the mulch it creates. Well worth it!read more
Joe Buckingham
Joe Buckingham
17:53 26 Mar 22
The BX42S wood chipper was received in early March. The unit was packaged in a heavy cage to help prevent shipping... damage. After assembly I connected unit to my tractor and started using it. It has been able to handle any branches that I put into it up to about 4 1/2 inches. I would recommend this unit to anyone that needs a wood chipper.read more
Frank Perugini
Frank Perugini
01:35 15 Nov 21
Dealing with Ryan B. of Victory Tractor Implements was a pleasure. Everything Ryan said was truthful and correct. ... Shipment was a breeze Ryan supplied me with the tracking info and I was able to see where and when I would receive my chipper. Thanks again Frankread more
Brian Adams
Brian Adams
17:51 30 Oct 21
I bought the 56" embankment flail mower and couldn't be more satisfied. Works like a champ. Delivery was quick and... assembly was easy. I would highly recommend this company and mower.read more
Kelly Smith
Kelly Smith
17:15 10 Oct 21
Uwe is super helpful. Great product, great price. New flail makes my place look a lot nicer as I can mow vertically... and keep the brush back and neat!read more
Ken Love
Ken Love
20:44 09 Oct 21
Prompt delivery…Awesome EMSD-56 flail mower, Awesome Support.. Since I never owned a flail mower, I had questions... regarding what turned out to be normal operational sounds, etc. I was reluctant to call, but I must say the person that answered the phone was very knowledgeable of the product and treated me with the the utmost respect and kindness.Mower works great and far exceeds expectations!!Thank You Victory Tractor for an Awesome Experience!!!read more
Dale Walter
Dale Walter
16:15 13 Jun 21
Great wood chipper at a great price!My 23 Hp Massey Sub Compact handles this beautifully, up to 4".Would highly... recommend to a friend.read more
S R
S R
19:58 22 May 21
My BX42S has exceeded my expectations. Hooked up to my Kubota 26hp tractor it chips 5 inch pine without any problem. 5... inch hardwood goes in my wood stove so I have not tried that. Communication with the company is excellent. Thanks Victory!read more
Ryan Getchell
Ryan Getchell
07:46 15 Apr 21
I just recently purchased the MDWC1500 wood chipper from Victory Tractor for cleaning up around the overgrown fields of... our farm, arrived on time, setup was easy, very well built and rugged chipper! It has no problem chipping 3inch diameter brush. What a great investment for cleaning up around the farm! It did come with a damaged drive belt but a phone call to my local auto parts store and they had the belt in stock. For the price I highly recommend this machine to any small farm/homeownerread more
Doug McCracken
Doug McCracken
21:37 06 Feb 21
I have the BCRL 145 on a 30 HP Kubota, I mow several banks around my property, and a walking trail around 72 acre... field. best mower I ever used.read more
RW REYNOLDS
RW REYNOLDS
13:09 15 Jan 21
Great prices , didn't get my flail mower from them but they knew exactly what parts I needed , very helpful, will be... back when I need more parts!!read more
Greg Davis
Greg Davis
22:56 06 Sep 20
It is a pleasure working with the staff at Victory. We purchased an offset flail mower from them several years ago for... mowing the berms of our rail-trail and it is holding up well and does a nice job We needed to replace a lost tooth on the mower and got the replacement parts quickly.read more
Raymond Paullin
Raymond Paullin
21:09 17 Aug 20
Excellent transaction from start to finish. Uwe was prompt responding to questions, my plow shipped in great shape and... I'm ready for winter.read more
Offshore Explorer Scott Dodgson
Offshore Explorer Scott Dodgson
21:11 07 Apr 20
Uwe was very helpful and professional. Great guy to do business with!
Next Reviews
js_loader

Recent Posts

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x